I’ve written about this before but seeing that the MTRCB is still in the process of engaging in a pissing match with ABS-CBN I’m posting about how being a repeater (the “insult” hurled by Rosanna Roces on the teachers) is actually taken in light of evidence with DI (Direct Instruction) is a convoluted form of praise. To be a repeater is a form of acceptance for most teachers. I am unremarkable. I am a cog. I am a replaceable cog. To accept this is in some ways accepting that student’s learning is more important than the sense of validation that people crave from other people. Truly heroic.<\/p>\n
In Super Crunchers<\/a>, Ian Ayres argues that just such a method exists.\u00a0 Overall, Super Crunchers is a light but entertaining account of how large amounts of data and cheap computing power are improving forecasting and decision making in social science, government and business.\u00a0 I enjoyed the book.\u00a0 Chapter 7, however, was a real highlight.
\nAyres argues that large experimental studies have shown that the teaching method which works best is Direct Instruction (here<\/a> and here<\/a> are two non-academic discussions which summarizes much of the same academic evidence discussed in Ayres).\u00a0 In Direct Instruction the teacher follows a script, a carefully designed and evaluated script.\u00a0 As Ayres notes this is key:<\/p>\nDI is scalable.\u00a0 Its success isn’t contingent on the personality of some uber-teacher….You don’t need to be a genius to be an effective DI teacher.\u00a0 DI can be implemented in dozens upon dozens of classrooms with just ordinary teachers.\u00a0 You just need to be able to follow the script.<\/p><\/blockquote>\n
Contrary to what you might think, the data also show that DI does not impede creativity or self-esteem.\u00a0 The education establishment, however, hates DI because it is a threat to the power and prestige of teaching, they prefer the model of teacher as hero.\u00a0 As Ayres says “The education establishment is wedded to its pet theories regardless of what the evidence says.”\u00a0 As a result they have fought it tooth and nail so that “Direct Instruction, the oldest and most validated program, has captured only a little more than 1 percent of the grade-school market.”
\nPosted by Alex Tabarrok on September 27, 2007 at 08:20 AM
\nvia Marginal Revolution: Heroes are not Replicable<\/a>.<\/p><\/blockquote>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"I’ve written about this before but seeing that the MTRCB is still in the process of engaging in a pissing match with ABS-CBN I’m posting about how being a repeater (the “insult” hurled by Rosanna Roces on the teachers) is actually taken in light of evidence with DI (Direct Instruction) is a convoluted form of … <\/p>\n